Judge: Michael Small, Case: 24STCV06850, Date: 2025-03-06 Tentative Ruling
Case Number: 24STCV06850 Hearing Date: March 6, 2025 Dept: 57
PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO COMPEL FURTHER RESPONSES TO FORM INTERROGATORIES
No. 1.1. GRANT Response was incomplete
No. 2.8. DENY Objection was not waived and it is valid
No. 12.1 GRANT, unless as of the time of the hearing, Defendant has provided a Code-compliant further response as Defendant says in its opposition to the motion it intended to do.
No. 12.2 DENY Response was complete
No. 12.3 DENY Response was complete
No. 12.6 DENY Response was complete
No. 12.7 DENY Response was complete
No. 15.1 GRANT, unless as of the time of the hearing, Defendant has provided a Code-compliant further response as Defendant says in its opposition to the motion it intended to do.
No. 17.1 GRANT, unless as of the time of the hearing, Defendant has provided a Code-compliant further response as Defendant says in its opposition to the motion it intended to do.
PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO COMPEL FURTHER RESPONSES TO SPECIAL INTERROGATORIES
No. 1 GRANT, unless as of the time of the hearing, Defendant has provided a Code-compliant further response as Defendant says in its opposition to the motion it intended to do.
No. 4 GRANT, unless as of the time of the hearing, Defendant has provided a Code-compliant further response as Defendant says in its opposition to the motion it intended to do.
No. 6 GRANT
No. 8 GRANT
No. 9 DENY Overbroad. That objection is not waived and is valid.
No. 11. DENY Response is complete
No. 12 GRANT, unless as of the time of the hearing, Defendant has provided a Code-compliant further response as Defendant says in its opposition to the motion it intended to do.
No. 13 GRANT
No. 14 Deny Response is complete
No. 15 GRANT
No. 16 GRANT
No. 17 Deny. Objections are not waived. Irrelevant -- question is about a vehicle with a different model and year from the vehicle that is the subject of this action. Also overbroad.
No. 18 Deny Objections are not waived. Irrelevant -- question is about a vehicle with a different model and year from the vehicle that is the subject of this action. Also overbroad.
No. 19 Deny Objections are not waived. Question calls for premature disclosure of an expert opinion.
No. 20 GRANT
No. 21 DENY. It is redundant of No. 20
PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO COMPEL FURTHER RESPONSES TO REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS
The Court will discuss this motion with counsel at the hearing.